Call Us! 1-877-672-1672

Separation of Church and School — by World Magazine

by Mickey McLean at World Magazine

The struggle over the governance of Erskine College and Seminary continues

The ongoing battle between the board of trustees of Erskine College and Erskine Seminary and their founding denomination, the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, over the governance of the schools remains unresolved following the ARPC’s annual denominational meeting that ended Thursday. ARPC pastors and ruling elders, who make up the delegates to the denomination’s highest court, the General Synod, voted to appoint committees to continue to study the issue and report back at next year’s annual meeting.

In making the motion to continue to study the situation, former ARPC Synod moderator Steve Maye said, according to a reporter for The Aquila Report, that if Erskine cannot become a faithful institution between now and next year’s Synod meeting, then the two institutions should part ways “so that peace would reign.” Maye’s motion received overwhelming approval by the delegates.

The controversy centers on the right of the ARPC Synod, which appoints members of the board of trustees, to be able to remove board members with cause. At the 2011 Synod meeting, the Erskine board was directed to revise its charter and bylaws to clarify the relationship between church and schools and acknowledge that the Synod, which is slated to give the college and seminary $431,000 in funding this coming year, has the power to remove board members when necessary.

In February, the board, which had representatives at last year’s Synod agreeing to the directive, refused to make the necessary changes to the charter and bylaws. Among its reasons for declining, the board cited accreditation agencies’ demand that the board be autonomous.

Eleven members of Erskine’s board submitted a “minority report” in May disputing many of the majority members’ objections to the Synod’s directive. The minority group said that accreditation is not an issue and that several other similar Christian colleges had such relationships with their founding denominations without any consequence to their accreditation status.

During Thursday’s debate, according to The Aquila Report, delegate Mark Ross said he had spoken with several accreditation representatives who told him they would be closely monitoring the situation to make sure the Synod did not take any “hostile” action toward the schools, warning against “blackmailing” Erskine by withholding funds.

Delegate Paul Mulner responded that it wasn’t blackmail for the church to ask one of its agencies to comply with a directive in order to continue to receive funding, but that it was blackmail for accreditation agencies to threaten the Synod in the decisions it makes in order to run its own schools.

William Evans, an ordained minister in the ARPC and chairman of Erskine College’s Department of Bible, Religion, and Philosophy, sees a possible split on the horizon.

“A key question for the Synod at this point is continue reading on the World Magazine website . . .

For more, see “Keeping the faith,” by Timothy Dalrymple, June 4, 2011; “Reclaiming Erskine,” by Joel Belz, March 27, 2010; and “Looking for a miracle” by Joel Belz, July 4, 2009.

More Posts in the Same Category

Erskine College

Erskine Theological Seminary
  • Erskine Hopeful for Continued Dialogue with ARP Synod Erskine trustees look forward to a continued, cooperative, and mutually beneficial relationship with the ARP General Synod. Every message has at least two parts: content and delivery. Delivery becomes especially important when the content of a message is not what the recipient is hoping for, or when previous interactions have been difficult. So while the ...
  • Dr. Hering examines litigation in 1 Corinthians 6 In response to questions about appropriate Christian uses of the secular courts, Professor James Hering of Erskine Theological Seminary has written an exegetical study of 1 Corinthians 6.
  • Erskine Alumni Survey Summary Between September and December 2011, the Erskine Alumni Association conducted a survey that sought to better understand giving trends and perspectives among Erskine alumni. If you were among those who participated, thank you for your feedback. About 26% of those asked to participate responded, yielding a wealth of information and insight from nearly a thousand ...
  • Erskine Seminary Student in Christianity Today David Howell, a student in the Master of Divinity degree program at Erskine, appears in a special section of the current Christianity Today. The “Rediscovering the Book” section includes an article on distance learning, in which David and  his family are featured in a sidebar. David is a candidate for the ministry in Foothills Presbytery of ...
  • 20 Pastors Make First Erskine Seminary Pilgrimage to Israel On August 19th, twenty pilgrims, most of them Associate Reformed Presbyterian pastors, departed our shores for a 2-week Holy Land tour. Unlike many Holy Land excursions, this particular trip was designed for pastors, with an intentional emphasis placed upon their retreat and renewal. Participants were mid-career pastors who had never had the opportunity to visit ...

Leave a Comment